Adam Minha

Probably the best eye liner I own. It doesn’t smudge easy. Stays on almost all day. And it’s so easy to draw on. The color is dark. And it’s pretty smooth to draw.

Mrs. Dukecat

This is my favorite eyeliner- hands down!! I don't think I've experienced an eyeliner that was so easy to use and so long-lasting without giving me the raccoon eyes! It glides on well and lasts a full night without smudging or rubbing off on anything.Keep in mind, while this eyeliner does not rub off or smudge, it DOES flake off... which makes removal easier, but it does look strange if you are pulling an all-nighter at a club or at home with the newborn- it CAN flake off... later... but hold...

Christina

This is the best eyeliner I have ever used (and I have tried a lot). It stays on all day. I just wish it came in different colors such as brown and navy. I am 76 yrs old and feel like black is too harsh on me now. (Which is why I am trying different brands, trying to find one that stays on all day in a lighter color). UD if you read this, please offer lighter colors!

Paige

I got my first liquid liner from Sephora a couple years back and I've finally finished that liner. I was overjoyed to find that Amazon sold it.Packaging: 0/5The liner had hairs sticking in different directions. It almost felt like a used product or the pen was slammed in incorrectly.Longevity of liner: 5/5I have oily eyelids because of my heavy epicanthic fold. A lot of eyeliners tend to smudge after an hour or two. This eyeliner is always perfect at the end of the night or after a swim in th...

Cathy JKM

I'm a huge Stila fan, for years I've bought the waterproof black thin tip liner, but the last two ran out very fast. So I decided to try this one, got a great price on prime day. Well worth the try, I love it's ease to apply, lasts all day, STAYS ON, and the tube is bigger. I think this should last longer.